How to Taste Olive Oil Like a Judge

How to Taste Olive Oil Like a Judge

Most of us only ever taste olive oil on something, whether that's bread, salad or a sauce. Tasting it on its own, the way a trained judge does, takes five minutes and a spoonful of oil, and it changes how you'll choose and use it from then on.

At the 2026 SA Olive Awards in September, every oil was judged blind by a trained panel. You don't need a seat on that panel to taste like one, though. Here's how.

How the Professionals Do It

Judges follow a method set by the International Olive Council. Panels of 8 to 12 tasters work in silence, each with about 15ml of oil in a small covered glass kept at around 28°C, the temperature at which aromas come through most clearly. Sessions run mid-morning, when taste and smell are sharpest, and nobody arrives smelling of coffee or perfume.

At home, you only need to borrow the approach.

What You'll Need

A small glass, one to two tablespoons of Extra Virgin Olive Oil, a slice of green apple and some water to reset your palate, and ideally a second oil to compare. Taste mid-morning, at least half an hour after coffee.

Five Steps

Warm it. Cover the glass with one hand, cup the base with the other and swirl for a minute so the aroma builds.

Smell it. Uncover and breathe in slowly for about half a minute. You might pick up cut grass, tomato leaf, herbs, artichoke, green apple or ripe fruit.

Sip it. Take about half a teaspoon and let it coat your whole mouth.

Slurp it. Draw a few short breaths in over the oil. It feels odd, but it carries the aroma up the back of your nose, where much of the flavour is actually perceived.

Swallow a little. Some of a great oil's character only shows up in the throat.

What Judges Score

Fruitiness is the aroma of fresh, healthy olives, leaning green and grassy or soft and ripe depending on the variety. Without it, an oil can't be graded extra virgin.

Bitterness sits at the back of the tongue and comes from green or just-turning olives. In a good oil it's balanced, never harsh.

Pepperiness, or pungency, is that catch in the throat that's typical of early-season oils. If a good oil makes you cough, take it as a compliment.

Together, these three explain the "delicate", "medium" and "robust" on a label. They describe intensity, not quality.

Why Judges Taste Blind

Official tasting glasses are dark, usually deep blue, so colour can't sway the verdict. Good oil ranges from pale gold to deep green, and the colour tells you very little about what's in the glass.

Red Flags

An extra virgin oil must be free of defects. Rancid oil tastes flat and stale, usually from age or poor storage. Fusty or musty notes are earthy or mouldy, from olives left too long before pressing, while winey oil is sharp and sour from fermentation. If it tastes dull, trust your palate.

Try It Side by Side

Comparing two oils is where it all clicks, and Mardouw's XXV range makes it easy. Start with XXV Delicate, a soft, balanced and herbaceous oil made mainly from Mission olives. Refresh with apple and water, then move on to XXV Intense, a herbaceous, peppery oil made mainly from Coratina olives. Both come from the foot of the Langeberg Mountains near Swellendam, so the difference you taste comes down to the olive and its intensity. Stop at four oils, since after that everything starts to taste the same.

The Jezreel Standard

We don't make our own oil. We find the estates that get these fundamentals right and bring their bottles to your door, asking the same questions a judge does every time: is it fresh, clean and balanced? Now you can ask them too.

Set up your own tasting at home. Order Mardouw XXV Delicate and Mardouw XXV Intense together, and taste the difference for yourself.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.